Spoiler Warning, Then the Honest State of the List
Spoilers ahead. This guide names story missions and the decisions inside them, starting with Chapter 1. Read only as far as you have played if you want the rest to land fresh.
Here is the honest starting point: GTA 6 does have choices with consequences, but the fully documented list is still short. Game8’s per-chapter choices guide, the source this article follows, currently records three Chapter 1 decisions, and it flags its own list as a work in progress.
What surrounds those three prompts matters just as much. Your wider behaviour feeds two standing systems, your Criminal Profile and your relationship level with your partner, and both react to choices long after a prompt disappears. This guide covers the prompts first, then the systems.
Key Takeaways
- Game8 currently documents three Chapter 1 choices: one in Pipework, one in Hey Arnold!, and one in Buck Me!.
- Killing Arnold gives Jason a Hardened Criminal Profile; sparing him gives a Restrained one, per Game8.
- The Buck Me! bank choice changes nothing: both answers draw the same response from the bank.
- Missions cannot be replayed as you progress, per Game8, so manual saves before big prompts are your only way back.
- Mission choice prompts can also raise or lower your relationship level, per Game8’s beginner guide.
- No verified branching endings are documented yet; anyone claiming a full ending list on day one is guessing.
Part 1 — Pipework: The Mandy Question
The first documented choice is really a documented refusal. In the Chapter 1 mission Pipework, players look for a way to sleep with a character named Mandy, and Game8’s answer is blunt: no, you cannot sleep with Mandy during Pipework.
That fits the game’s wider rule. All intimacy in GTA 6 sits between Jason and Lucia, and the paid encounter mechanic from older games was removed entirely.
Why include a non-choice in a choices guide? Because it sets expectations early. GTA 6 will present people who seem like optional romantic detours, and the game consistently closes those doors so the central partnership stays central.
Treat Pipework as the tutorial for that idea. When the game hints at a side romance, the consequence is that there is no consequence: the story moves on with the couple intact.

Part 2 — Hey Arnold!: Kill or Spare Arnold
This is the first real decision. At the end of the Chapter 1 mission Hey Arnold!, Jason corners Arnold, and the game asks whether to kill him or spare him.
Game8 records the consequences as profile changes. Killing Arnold results in Jason getting a Hardened Criminal Profile. Sparing Arnold results in a Restrained Criminal Profile, and Game8 adds that sparing him may also grant a chance to reunite with him later in the main story.
Other launch walkthroughs add a caution worth knowing. Several report that Arnold leaves the story either way, with no payout, item or follow-up scene found for either branch so far. That reporting conflicts with Game8’s reunion hint, so treat the reunion as unconfirmed until later chapters are fully documented.
The safe reading today: the guaranteed consequence is the profile shift, not a story fork. Choose based on the kind of criminal you want Jason recorded as, which our guide to the GTA 6 Criminal Profile system explains in full.
One more practical wrinkle comes from launch streams: choices like this one appear to run on a timer, and waiting too long can let the moment resolve without you. That detail is reported from gameplay clips rather than documented in guides, so treat it as reported, and decide promptly either way.
Part 3 — Buck Me!: Say Nothing or Saved Cash
The Chapter 1 mission Buck Me! involves opening a bank account, and it presents a smaller, dialogue-style choice: say nothing, or mention saved cash.
Game8 records the consequence, and it is a joke at the player’s expense. Regardless of your choice, the bank gives the same response: “Your credit is dogshit.”
Not every prompt in GTA 6 is a fork. Some are flavour, there to make a conversation feel responsive while the outcome stays fixed, and Buck Me! is the clearest early example.
The mission still matters beyond the gag. Completing Buck Me! is tied to systems that open up around your money and phone apps, so the real consequence of the mission is what it unlocks, not what you said at the counter.

Part 4 — The Two Systems Every Choice Feeds
The Criminal Profile is GTA 6’s standing record of how you operate. Game8’s beginner guide explains that doing crimes does not move it; how violently you do them does. There are five profiles, running from Professional and Hardened at the controlled end to Violent, Psycho and Irredeemable at the excessive end.
One warning from that guide deserves bold treatment in your memory: once you reach Irredeemable, you are locked into that profile. Most choices nudge the scale, but the far end of it is a one-way door, which makes early restraint worth more than it first looks.
The relationship level is the second system. Game8 describes four levels between Jason and Lucia that you can move up and down freely through the story. Shared activities, greetings, gifts of food or clothes and physical affection raise it; neglect, ignored messages and abandoning your partner lower it.
Mission prompts plug straight into it. Game8 notes that certain missions carry choice prompts that grant a relationship buff or debuff, with the reaction visible in the moment, so you can usually tell at once whether your partner approved. For the romance itself, see whether Jason and Lucia are a couple.
Part 5 — How to Protect a Playthrough You Care About
Game8’s choices guide carries the warning that shapes everything else: since there is no way to replay missions while progressing through the main story, weigh your options before committing to any choice.
The practical answer is manual saves. Keep a save from before each chapter’s big missions, in its own slot, and never overwrite your only pre-choice save with a post-choice one. If curiosity wins, you can load back and take the other branch without restarting the game.
Know what you are protecting against. Most documented consequences so far are profile labels, relationship shifts and unlocks, not lost missions. The genuinely costly story locks are a separate topic, covered in our guide to GTA 6 missables and points of no return.
And keep perspective on endings. No verified source has documented branching endings yet, and the ending count itself remains unconfirmed at launch. If a choice feels enormous, its documented weight is probably in the two standing systems, not in a secret finale.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many choices are documented in GTA 6 so far?
Game8’s per-chapter guide currently documents three, all in Chapter 1: the Mandy question in Pipework, kill or spare Arnold in Hey Arnold!, and the bank dialogue in Buck Me!. The guide is marked as a work in progress.
Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
Game8 says killing Arnold gives Jason a Hardened Criminal Profile, while sparing him gives a Restrained one and may allow a later reunion. Other walkthroughs report Arnold exits the story either way, so the profile shift is the confirmed difference.
What happens if you spare Arnold?
Per Game8, Jason gains a Restrained Criminal Profile, and a later reunion is possible. That reunion is not yet confirmed by other launch walkthroughs, so treat it as unconfirmed.
Does the Buck Me! choice change anything?
No. Game8 records that both answers, saying nothing or mentioning saved cash, draw the identical response from the bank: “Your credit is dogshit.” It is a flavour choice.
Can you replay a mission to change a choice?
No. Game8 warns there is no way to replay missions while progressing through the main story. A manual save made before the prompt is the only route back.
Can you sleep with Mandy in Pipework?
No. Game8’s choices guide answers this directly: you cannot sleep with Mandy during Pipework, matching the game’s rule that intimacy is exclusive to Jason and Lucia.
Do choices affect Jason and Lucia’s relationship?
Yes. Game8’s beginner guide says certain mission choice prompts grant a relationship buff or debuff, and you can usually see your partner’s reaction immediately.
What is the Criminal Profile consequence system?
It is a five-step record of how violently you operate, from Professional to Irredeemable, per Game8. Crimes themselves do not move it; unnecessary violence does, and reaching Irredeemable locks you in.
Are there choices in later chapters?
Almost certainly, but they are not fully documented yet. Game8’s list currently covers Chapter 1 and is being updated as its team progresses, so later chapters should be treated as unknown rather than choice-free.
Do choices change the ending of GTA 6?
No verified reporting documents branching endings at launch. The confirmed consequences are profile changes, relationship shifts and unlocks, and any full ending claims circulating now are unverified.
Final Verdict on Choice in Leonida
GTA 6’s choices are real but narrower than the hype suggests: one genuine early fork in Hey Arnold!, a flavour gag in Buck Me!, a firm refusal in Pipework, and two standing systems quietly scoring everything else you do.
Play the prompts by the criminal and the partner you want to be, keep a manual save before the big ones, and distrust any day-one list that claims to know how every decision ends. The documented list will grow; this is its verified shape today.








